Volume 48 - Article 11 | Pages 321–338  

The question of the human mortality plateau: Contrasting insights by longevity pioneers

By Linh Hoang Khanh Dang, Carlo Giovanni Camarda, France Meslé, Nadine Ouellette, Jean-Marie Robine, Jacques Vallin

Abstract

Background: The debate about limits to the human life span is often based on outcomes from mortality at the oldest ages among longevity pioneers. To this day, scholars disagree on the existence of a late-life plateau in human mortality. Amid various statistical analysis frameworks, the parametric proportional hazards model is a simple and valuable approach to test the presence of a plateau by assuming different baseline hazard functions on individual-level data.

Objective: We replicate and propose some improvements to the methods of Barbi et al. (2018) to explore whether death rates reach a plateau at later ages in the French population as it does for Italians in the original study.

Methods: We use a large set of exceptionally reliable data covering the most recently extinct birth cohorts, 1883–1901, where all 3,789 members who were born and died in France, were followed from age 105 onward. Individual life trajectories are modeled by a proportional hazards model with fixed covariates (gender, birth cohort) and a Gompertz baseline hazard function.

Results: In contrast with Barbi et al. (2018)’s results, our Gompertz slope parameter estimate is statistically different from zero across all model specifications, suggesting death rates continue to increase beyond 105 years old in the French population. In addition, we find no significant birth cohort effect but a significant male disadvantage in mortality after age 105.

Conclusions: Using the best data currently available, we did not find any evidence of a mortality plateau in French individuals aged 105 and older.

Contribution: The evidence for the existence of an extreme-age mortality plateau in recent Italian cohorts does not extend to recent French cohorts. Caution in generalizations is advised, and we encourage further studies on long-lived populations with high-quality data.

Author's Affiliation

• Linh Hoang Khanh Dang - Institut National d'Études Démographiques (INED), France EMAIL
• Carlo Giovanni Camarda - Institut National d'Études Démographiques (INED), France EMAIL
• France Meslé - Institut National d'Études Démographiques (INED), France EMAIL
• Nadine Ouellette - Université de Montréal, Canada EMAIL
• Jean-Marie Robine - Institut National de la Santé et de la Recherche Médicale (INSERM), France EMAIL
• Jacques Vallin - Institut National d'Études Démographiques (INED), France EMAIL

Other articles by the same author/authors in Demographic Research

Adult mortality patterns in the former Soviet Union’s southern tier: Armenia and Georgia in comparative perspective
Volume 36 - Article 19

Insight on 'typical' longevity: An analysis of the modal lifespan by leading causes of death in Canada
Volume 35 - Article 17

Mortality in the Caucasus: An attempt to re-estimate recent mortality trends in Armenia and Georgia
Volume 22 - Article 23

Geographical diversity of cause-of-death patterns and trends in Russia
Volume 12 - Article 13

Life expectancy in two Caucasian countries. How much due to overestimated population?
Volume 5 - Article 7

Convergences and divergences in mortality: A new approach of health transition
Special Collection 2 - Article 2

Frailty at death: An examination of multiple causes of death in four low mortality countries in 2017
Volume 49 - Article 2

Smooth constrained mortality forecasting
Volume 41 - Article 38

Is the age difference between partners related to women's earnings?
Volume 41 - Article 15

The mystery of Japan's missing centenarians explained
Volume 26 - Article 11

Changes in the age-at-death distribution in four low mortality countries: A nonparametric approach
Volume 25 - Article 19

Occupational inequalities in health expectancies in France in the early 2000s: Unequal chances of reaching and living retirement in good health
Volume 25 - Article 12

Revisiting the mortality of France and Italy with the multiple-cause-of-death approach
Volume 23 - Article 28

Arthur Roger Thatcher's contributions to longevity research: A Reflexion
Volume 22 - Article 18

The compression of deaths above the mode
Volume 22 - Article 17

Dissecting the compression of mortality in Switzerland, 1876-2005
Volume 21 - Article 19

Mortality in Central and Eastern Europe: Long-term trends and recent upturns
Special Collection 2 - Article 3

Most recent similar articles in Demographic Research

Excess mortality associated with HIV: Survey estimates from the PHIA project
Volume 51 - Article 38    | Keywords: excess mortality, HIV/AIDS, mortality

Is single parenthood increasingly an experience of less-educated mothers? A European comparison over five decades
Volume 51 - Article 34    | Keywords: age, children, cross-national comparison, education, Europe, family life course, inequality, single motherhood

A Bayesian model for age at death with cohort effects
Volume 51 - Article 33    | Keywords: age at death, Bayesian approach, cohort effects, Italy, mortality

On the relationship between life expectancy, modal age at death, and the threshold age of the life table entropy
Volume 51 - Article 24    | Keywords: Gompertz law, life expectancy, lifespan variation, longevity, mode, mortality

The role of sex and age in seasonal mortality – the case of Poland
Volume 51 - Article 17    | Keywords: mortality, Poland, seasonality, sex differences