Social-class differences in spacing and stopping during the historical fertility transition: Insights from cure models

Edoardo Redivo; Martin Dribe; Francesco Scalone

doi:10.4054/DemRes.2024.51.40

Volume 51 - Article 40 | Pages 1257–1298

Social-class differences in spacing and stopping during the historical fertility transition: Insights from cure models

By Edoardo Redivo, Martin Dribe, Francesco Scalone

Date received:

21 Nov 2023

Date published:

20 Nov 2024

Word count:

7150

Keywords:

cure model, fertility transition, social class, spacing, stopping

DOI:

10.4054/DemRes.2024.51.40

Download PDF
Submit a Response Letter

Abstract

Background: There is a long-standing debate about the role of spacing and stopping in the fertility transition, fueled by a lack of methods to appropriately model spacing and stopping. Traditional event-history analysis cannot distinguish between the two processes in analyzing the determinants of birth risks, and attempts to separately model spacing and stopping have been criticized from a methodological point of view.

Objective: Our aim is to assess the role of spacing and stopping in the historic fertility transition generally, and the role of social-class differences in the fertility decline more specifically.

Methods: We use cure models, which are extensions of traditional survival analysis, to distinguish the impact of stopping and spacing on fertility. The models are applied to individual-level data for a region in southern Sweden between 1813 and 1967.

Results: Both spacing and stopping played a role in the fertility transition, but stopping emerged earlier for all parities after the first and had a greater effect on the reduction in fertility. Higher social classes were forerunners in the fertility transition but we do not find that spacing and stopping operated in different ways by social class.

Conclusions: Our findings indicate that stopping had an earlier and more substantial impact on the fertility transition than spacing. However, the patterns of the two behaviors were very similar between social classes.

Contribution: Our study is one of very few that applies cure models to distinguish spacing and stopping in the fertility transition, and the first to our knowledge that uses this approach to study class differences in the fertility decline.