Volume 51 - Article 36 | Pages 1125–1166  

Educational trends in cohort fertility by birth order: A comparison of England and Wales, Scotland, and Northern Ireland

By Bernice Kuang, Ann Berrington, Sarah Christison, Hill Kulu

Abstract

Background: Over the past few decades, cohort fertility rates in the different countries of the United Kingdom (England and Wales, Scotland, and Northern Ireland) have diverged, yet the role of parity-specific patterns, including childlessness, is not known. Studies across Europe have found a reversal in the educational gradient of childlessness from positive to negative, which has been attributed to economic uncertainty, new patterns of parity progression, and increased polarization of behaviours across educational subgroups, raising the question of how the United Kingdom fits into these emerging trends.

Objective: This paper uses large-scale administrative data from each of the United Kingdom’s countries to identify how childlessness and childbearing at higher birth orders are driving these differences and to explore potential explanations.

Results: For the birth cohorts 1956–1978, we find a persistently positive educational pattern of childlessness across all UK countries, albeit with smaller educational differences in Northern Ireland. We also find, across educational groups, divergent country trends in family size distribution, with Scotland trending towards smaller families but not higher levels of childlessness, and Northern Ireland having larger families. England and Wales remain firmly entrenched in the two-child norm. Family size differences between countries are not explained by postponement alone since mean age at first birth is relatively similar across countries.

Contribution: Our findings show that the UK countries have unique fertility regimes, emphasizing the value of examining countries separately for their different empirical contributions to the unfolding patterns of contemporary cohort fertility change in Europe.

Author's Affiliation

Other articles by the same author/authors in Demographic Research

Union formation and fertility amongst immigrants from Pakistan and their descendants in the United Kingdom: A multichannel sequence analysis
Volume 48 - Article 10

Investigating the application of generalized additive models to discrete-time event history analysis for birth events
Volume 47 - Article 22

Family life transitions, residential relocations, and housing in the life course: Current research and opportunities for future work: Introduction to the Special Collection on “Separation, Divorce, and Residential Mobility in a Comparative Perspective”
Volume 43 - Article 2

Separation, divorce, and housing tenure: A cross-country comparison
Volume 41 - Article 39

Homeownership after separation: A longitudinal analysis of Finnish register data
Volume 41 - Article 29

Union dissolution and housing trajectories in Britain
Volume 41 - Article 7

A decade of life-course research on fertility of immigrants and their descendants in Europe
Volume 40 - Article 46

The role of education in the intersection of partnership transitions and motherhood in Europe and the United States
Volume 39 - Article 27

Co-ethnic marriage versus intermarriage among immigrants and their descendants: A comparison across seven European countries using event-history analysis
Volume 39 - Article 17

Social policies, separation, and second birth spacing in Western Europe
Volume 37 - Article 37

Cross-national differences in women's repartnering behaviour in Europe: The role of individual demographic characteristics
Volume 37 - Article 8

Why does fertility remain high among certain UK-born ethnic minority women?
Volume 35 - Article 49

Introduction to research on immigrant and ethnic minority families in Europe
Volume 35 - Article 2

The fertility of recent migrants to England and Wales
Volume 34 - Article 36

Educational differences in timing and quantum of childbearing in Britain: A study of cohorts born 1940−1969
Volume 33 - Article 26

Commitment and the changing sequence of cohabitation, childbearing, and marriage: Insights from qualitative research in the UK
Volume 33 - Article 12

Union formation and dissolution among immigrants and their descendants in the United Kingdom
Volume 33 - Article 10

Towards a new understanding of cohabitation: Insights from focus group research across Europe and Australia
Volume 31 - Article 34

The changing determinants of UK young adults' living arrangements
Volume 25 - Article 20

Premarital cohabitation and divorce: Support for the "Trial Marriage" Theory?
Volume 23 - Article 31

High Suburban Fertility: Evidence from Four Northern European Countries
Volume 21 - Article 31

Migration and union dissolution in a changing socio-economic context: The case of Russia
Volume 17 - Article 27

Fertility differences by housing type: The effect of housing conditions or of selective moves?
Volume 17 - Article 26

Family change and migration in the life course: An introduction
Volume 17 - Article 19

Most recent similar articles in Demographic Research

Higher incomes are increasingly associated with higher fertility: Evidence from the Netherlands, 2008–2022
Volume 51 - Article 26    | Keywords: fertility, income, inequalities, Netherlands, parenthood

The short- and long-term determinants of fertility in Uruguay
Volume 51 - Article 10    | Keywords: fertility, panel data, stages of female reproductive life, time series, Uruguay

The big decline: Lowest-low fertility in Uruguay (2016–2021)
Volume 50 - Article 16    | Keywords: adolescent fertility, birth order, fertility, Latin America, ultra-low fertility, Uruguay

Cohort fertility of immigrants to Israel from the former Soviet Union
Volume 50 - Article 13    | Keywords: age at first birth, assimilation, cohort analysis, fertility, immigration, parity, religiosity

Fertility decline, changes in age structure, and the potential for demographic dividends: A global analysis
Volume 50 - Article 9    | Keywords: age structure, demographic dividend, demographic transition, fertility, migration, population momentum, working-age population