Volume 29 - Article 22 | Pages 579–616  

Validation of spatially allocated small area estimates for 1880 Census demography

By Matt Ruther, Galen Maclaurin, Stefan Leyk, Barbara Buttenfield, Nicholas Nagle

Abstract

Objective: This paper details the validation of a methodology which spatially allocates Census microdata to census tracts, based on known, aggregate tract population distributions. To protect confidentiality, public-use microdata contain no spatial identifiers other than the code indicating the Public Use Microdata Area (PUMA) in which the individual or household is located. Confirmatory information including the location of microdata households can only be obtained in a Census Research Data Center (CRDC). Due to restrictions in place at CRDCs, a systematic procedure for validating the spatial allocation methodology needs to be implemented prior to accessing CRDC data.

Methods: This study demonstrates and evaluates such an approach, using historical census data for which a 100% count of the full population is available at a fine spatial resolution. The approach described allows for testing of the behavior of a maximum entropy imputation and spatial allocation model under different specifications. The imputation and allocation is performed using a microdata sample of records drawn from the full 1880 Census enumeration and synthetic summary files created from the same source. The results of the allocation are then validated against the actual values from the 100% count of 1880.

Results: The results indicate that the validation procedure provides useful statistics, allowing an in-depth evaluation of the household allocation and identifying optimal configurations for model parameterization. This provides important insights as to how to design a validation procedure at a CRDC for spatial allocations using contemporary census data.

Author’s Affiliation

• Matt Ruther - University of Colorado Boulder, United States of America EMAIL
• Galen Maclaurin - University of Colorado Boulder, United States of America EMAIL
• Stefan Leyk - University of Colorado Boulder, United States of America EMAIL
• Barbara Buttenfield - University of Colorado Boulder, United States of America EMAIL
• Nicholas Nagle - University of Tennessee, United States of America EMAIL

Most recent similar articles in Demographic Research

Universal yet local: Estimating county-level fertility ideals and intentions in China
Volume 53 - Article 18    | Keywords: China, fertility intention, multilevel model, poststratification, small area estimation

Analyzing regional patterns of mortality data quality and adult mortality for small areas in Brazil, 1980–2010
Volume 51 - Article 44    | Keywords: Brazil, mortality differentials, small area estimation, spatial analysis

Which definition of migration better fits Facebook ‘expats’? A response using Mexican census data
Volume 50 - Article 39    | Keywords: census data, Facebook, international migration, Mexico, social media

Family inequality: On the changing educational gradient of family patterns in Western Germany
Volume 48 - Article 20    | Keywords: census data, descriptive analysis, divorce, educational inequality, family, Germany, marriage, partnership, time, trends

Small-area estimates from consumer trace data
Volume 47 - Article 27    | Keywords: calibration techniques, consumer data, nontraditional data, small area estimation