Volume 28 - Article 21 | Pages 613–636  

The impact of immigration under the defined-benefit pension system: An analysis incorporating assimilation costs

By Masatoshi Jinno

Abstract

Background: Recently, theoretical studies have started a discussion on how the influx of immigrants affects the finances of the host country.

Objective: This paper investigates whether admission of unskilled immigrants, whose children incur assimilation costs in order to become skilled workers, positively influences the net benefits for native residents and immigrants under a defined-benefit pension system (DB system). This paper also compared the results under a DB system with those under a defined-contribution pension system (DC system).

Methods: This paper theoretically calculates the net benefits for native residents and immigrants under a DB system and compares the values between under a DB system and under a DC system.

Results: The study has three main findings. (1) Under a DB system, native residents do not always become net beneficiaries, even if the government admits an unlimited number of immigrants. This is unlike the analysis under the DC system. (2) The net benefits for native residents caused by permitting a small (large) number of immigrants under the DB system becomes higher (lower) than that under the DC system in certain practical situations. (3) Even if all residents who have the right to vote prefer to admit immigrants, there is a possibility that the net benefits for the native residents may be negative.

Conclusions: When admitting immigrants, the government must pay attention to the assimilation costs which offspring of immigrants have to pay and the future generation’s right to vote because they are the main victims of the loss of benefits caused by the assimilation costs under DB system.

Author's Affiliation

• Masatoshi Jinno - Toyo University, Tokyo, Japan EMAIL

Most recent similar articles in Demographic Research

The intergenerational transmission of migration capital: The role of family migration history and lived migration experiences
Volume 50 - Article 29    | Keywords: childhood, emigration, Europe, immigration, life course

Mortality inequalities at retirement age between migrants and non-migrants in Denmark and Sweden
Volume 50 - Article 18    | Keywords: immigration, life expectancy, lifespan inequality, Nordic countries, pension age, pension policy

Cohort fertility of immigrants to Israel from the former Soviet Union
Volume 50 - Article 13    | Keywords: age at first birth, assimilation, cohort analysis, fertility, immigration, parity, religiosity

Reducing uncertainty in Delphi surveys: A case study on immigration to the EU
Volume 49 - Article 36    | Keywords: European Union, immigration, international migration, migration flows

Legal status and health disparities: An examination of health insurance coverage among the foreign-born
Volume 47 - Article 16    | Keywords: health insurance, immigration, imputation, legal status