Volume 30 - Article 7 | Pages 227–252  

Self-Reported Versus Performance-Based Measures of Physical Function: Prognostic Value for Survival

By Noreen Goldman, Dana Glei, Luis Rosero-Bixby, Shu-Ti Chiou, Maxine Weinstein

Abstract

Background: Although previous studies have indicated that performance assessments strongly predict future survival, few have evaluated the incremental value in the presence of controls for self-reported activity and mobility limitations.

Objective: We assess and compare the added value of four tests -- walking speed, chair stands, grip strength, and peak expiratory flow (PEF) -- for predicting all-cause mortality.

Methods: Using population-based samples of older adults in Costa Rica (n = 2290, aged 60+) and Taiwan (n = 1219, aged 53+), we estimate proportional hazards models of mortality for an approximate five-year period. Receiver Operator Characteristic (ROC) curves are used to assess the prognostic value of each performance assessment.

Results: Self-reported measures of physical limitations contribute substantial gains in mortality prediction, whereas performance-based assessments yield modest incremental gains. PEF provides the greatest added value, followed by grip strength. Our results suggest that including more than two performance assessments may provide little improvement in mortality prediction.

Conclusions: PEF and grip strength are often simpler to administer in home interview settings, impose less of a burden on some respondents, and, in the presence of self-reported limitations, appear to be better predictors of mortality than do walking speed or chair stands.

Comments: Being unable to perform the test is often a strong predictor of mortality, but these indicators are not well-defined. Exclusion rates vary by the specific task and are likely to depend on the underlying demographic, health, social and cultural characteristics of the sample.

Author's Affiliation

• Noreen Goldman - Princeton University, United States of America EMAIL
• Dana Glei - Georgetown University, United States of America EMAIL
• Luis Rosero-Bixby - Universidad de Costa Rica, Costa Rica EMAIL
• Shu-Ti Chiou - Health Promotion Administration, Taiwan EMAIL
• Maxine Weinstein - Georgetown University, United States of America EMAIL

Other articles by the same author/authors in Demographic Research

The vanishing advantage of longevity in Nicoya, Costa Rica: A cohort shift
Volume 49 - Article 27

Life expectancy loss among Native Americans during the COVID-19 pandemic
Volume 47 - Article 9

COVID-19 risk factors and mortality among Native Americans
Volume 45 - Article 39

Mexican mortality 1990‒2016: Comparison of unadjusted and adjusted estimates
Volume 44 - Article 30

Calloused hands, shorter life? Occupation and older-age survival in Mexico
Volume 42 - Article 32

Costa Rican mortality 1950‒2013: An evaluation of data quality and trends compared with other countries
Volume 40 - Article 29

High life expectancy and reversed socioeconomic gradients of elderly people in Mexico and Costa Rica
Volume 38 - Article 3

The declining effect of sibling size on children's education in Costa Rica
Volume 31 - Article 48

Is Latin America starting to retreat from early and universal childbearing?
Volume 20 - Article 9

The effects of war losses on mortality estimates for Italy: A first attempt
Volume 13 - Article 15

Introduction to the Special Collection “Human Mortality over Age, Time, Sex, and Place: The 1st HMD Symposium”
Volume 13 - Article 10

Most recent similar articles in Demographic Research

Uncovering disability-free grandparenthood in Italy between 1998 and 2016 using gender-specific decomposition
Volume 50 - Article 42    | Keywords: aging, decomposition, disability, grandparenthood, Italy

Two-dimensional contour decomposition: Decomposing mortality differences into initial difference and trend components by age and cause of death
Volume 50 - Article 41    | Keywords: decomposition methods, mortality

International completeness of death registration
Volume 50 - Article 38    | Keywords: data collection, death, mortality, statistics, sustainable development goals, vital registration

Incorporating subjective survival information in mortality and change in health status predictions: A Bayesian approach
Volume 50 - Article 36    | Keywords: Bayesian demography, health, mortality, self report, subjective mortality probabilities

Standardized mean age at death (MADstd): Exploring its potentials as a measure of human longevity
Volume 50 - Article 30    | Keywords: formal demography, life expectancy, mean age at death, mortality, standardization