Volume 21 - Article 9 | Pages 235–254  

Death distribution methods for estimating adult mortality: Sensitivity analysis with simulated data errors

By Kenneth Hill, Danzhen You, Yoonjoung Choi

Abstract

TThe General Growth Balance (GGB) and Synthetic Extinct Generations (SEG) methods have been widely used to evaluate the coverage of registered deaths in developing countries. However, relatively little is known about how the methods behave in the presence of different data errors. This paper applies the methods (both singly and in combination) using non-stable populations of known mortality to which various data distortions in a variety of combinations have been applied. Results show that the methods work very well when the only errors in the data are those for which the methods were developed. For other types of error, performance is more variable, but on average, adjusted mortality estimates using the methods are closer to the true values than the unadjusted. The methods do surprisingly well in the presence of typical patterns of age misreporting, though GGB is more sensitive to coverage errors that change with age; the Basic SEG method (e.g. not adjusting for any slope with age of completeness estimates) is very sensitive to changes in census coverage; but once slope is adjusted for changing census, coverage has little effect. Fitting to the age range 5+ to 65+ is clearly preferable to fitting to 15+ to 55+. Both GGB and SEG are very sensitive to net migration, which is an Achilles heel for all of the methodologies in this paper. In populations not greatly affected by migration, our results suggest that an optimal strategy would be to apply GGB to estimate census coverage change, adjust for it and then apply SEG; in populations affected by migration, applying both GGB and SEG, fitting both to the age range 30+ to 65+, and averaging the results appears best.

Author's Affiliation

• Kenneth Hill - Independent researcher, International EMAIL
• Danzhen You - United Nations Children's Fund (UNICEF), United States of America EMAIL
• Yoonjoung Choi - Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health, United States of America EMAIL

Other articles by the same author/authors in Demographic Research

Neonatal mortality in the developing world
Volume 14 - Article 18

Unconventional approaches to mortality estimation
Volume 13 - Article 12

Does age-adjusted measurement of contraceptive use better explain the relationship between fertility and contraception?
Volume 39 - Article 45

Using census data to measure maternal mortality: A review of recent experience
Volume 39 - Article 11

Measuring fertility through mobile‒phone based household surveys: Methods, data quality, and lessons learned from PMA2020 surveys
Volume 38 - Article 55

Most recent similar articles in Demographic Research

Sample selection bias in adult mortality estimates from mobile phone surveys: Evidence from 25 low- and middle-income countries
Volume 51 - Article 37    | Keywords: adult mortality, data collection, mobile phones, selection bias, sibling survival histories

Using household death questions from surveys to assess adult mortality in periods of health crisis: An application for Peru, 2018–2022
Volume 51 - Article 8    | Keywords: adult mortality, data quality, household surveys, Peru

Dynamics of the coefficient of variation of the age at death distribution
Volume 49 - Article 38    | Keywords: lifespan inequality, mathematical demography, sensitivity analysis, threshold age

The COVID-19 pandemic and fertility responses: TFR simulation analysis using parity progressions in South Korea
Volume 49 - Article 32    | Keywords: COVID-19, fertility intentions, marriage intentions, simulation

The vanishing advantage of longevity in Nicoya, Costa Rica: A cohort shift
Volume 49 - Article 27    | Keywords: adult mortality, blue zones, extreme longevity, long-lived populations, median life, old-age survival